Your Account | Help | Directory
Edmunds.com | Inside Line | CarSpace
You have 100 characters to use
Search for questions:
Categories
Question
Question Details
Asked: Jul 27, 2009 - 04:02 PM
Status: Closed
edmunds20
Passenger buckles seatbelt. The passenger unbuckles to get phone-accident happens-passenger needs head scan-who pay
A driver has a passenger, who buckles seatbelt. The passenger unbuckles the belt to get phone when an accident happens. The passenger needs a head scan. Does the driver's insurance cover the cost of the scan or does the passenger's medical insurace cover?
In Car Safety > Safe Driving In Car Insurance > Accidents In Car Insurance > Insurance Claims4 answers - 112 days ago
Watch this Question | Email to a Friend
Note: Per our Visitor Agreement, Edmunds.com does not guarantee the accuracy of any answers. We recommend that you use common sense when following any advice found here.
Answers
mr_shiftright
Date: Jul 27, 2009 Time: 07:12 PM
It's my understanding that you are responsible for your passenger's seat belt use. If they were unbuckled during a traffic stop, for instance, you'd get the ticket. It's possible in this case that your insurance company would sue HIS insurance company at a later date to recover the claim/loss. Actually this is an interesting question and I'm only throwing out ideas. I'd like to hear more about it myself, perhaps from an insurance expert.
colin_l
Date: Jul 27, 2009 Time: 10:44 PM
Ignoring the interesting aspect of the seat belt being unfastened, this would normally work by first depleting the personal injury protection of the driver(s) at fault in the accident, then the at-fault parties supplemental coverage (umbrella) if they have it, then finally the passenger's personal medical insurance if they have it.I'm with Shifty. I don't see the seatbelt as being all that relevant initially, unless some of the insurance specifically excludes coverage for non-belted passengers or something.
steve_
Date: Aug 02, 2009 Time: 12:52 AM
Interesting problem. I linked your post over to the Questions About Auto Insurance & Accidents CarSpace forum. Maybe someone over there will have some more to say about who pays.Feel free to click the Answer this Question button to reply and add other details (like, were you found at fault by the cops, and did the getting the phone contribute to the accident?).
oldfarmer50
Date: Aug 03, 2009 Time: 05:03 PM
The law usually hold the driver responsible for everything that goes on in the car. Thus if your passenger has dope on him you can get arrested when the cop pulls you over even though you didn't know he had it. By the same token, you are responsible to see that your passenger is belted in even if he/she is a knuklehead.It's kind of like the cheating spouse theory. Your wife has an affair and becomes pregnant. You are legally the father of the child and must pay support because the child was born while the two of you were married.Not fair but there you go.
OTHER QUESTIONS NEEDING ANSWERS
Top Safe Driving Experts
Edmunds Newsletter