Edmunds Answers



  • cadillac_luke 12/13/12 2:38 pm PST

    I'm not sure if I'm understanding what the question is here but let me try and give you my two cents.

    If you are at the dealership and the mechanic is telling you it's not worth it, I would find a different mechanic. Car dealerships typically incentivize their mechanics to talk existing customers into purchasing new vehicles over repairing the vehicle they have.

    With that being said, if you love this vehicle, I'd use this site and find out what the fair market value of your vehicle is. Consumer reports recommends spending no more money on repairs then the value of your current vehicle.

    An example, if the current value on your vehicle is $4000 and you can repair it for equal or less than that they recommend going with the repair. They back this position up by explaining spending $4000 on a vehicle that you know, is better than going out and buying another vehicle that may have similar or even worse problems than the vehicle you have. In short you know what your current vehicle is like and if it has not been nickel and diming you to death then a major repair may be in your best interest.

    I would look for a local independent automatic transmission specialist, take your vehicle to them and get an estimate. Then do some research on the better business bureau to make sure they are a reputable shop. Independent shops typically service their customers better as opposed to bringing it back to the dealer.

    I hope this helps,

    Good luck!


  • morin2 12/14/12 9:26 am PST

    That's good advice from cadillac luke. I would not use the dealer's service department in this case. An honest, qualified mechanic should be consulted. You should consider your options relative to their risks. The most expensive option would be to have a warranteed factory rebuild installed. That's also the lowest risk option. Less expensive would be to have a salvage yard transmission installed. These can even be found on ebay. Another option would be to have the failed or failing components of your transaxle replaced. That would require a skilled mechanic transmission specialist (not a national chain).


Top Transmission Experts View More

Rank Leader Points
1. karjunkie 16455
2. MrShift@Edmunds 15775
3. zaken1 4685
4. snowball2 2595
5. texases 2500
6. Stever@Edmunds 2075
7. Mr_Shiftright 2000