Answers

Ask Questions Answer Questions Browse Questions

Search for questions:

My Answers Profile

Question

Question Details

Asked: Feb 07, 2008 - 07:42 PM

Status: Closed

Body shop wants me to endorse the check over to them to pay for part on insurance claim. Should I?

Had a comprehensive claim. Hit a deer. The car is at the shop and they started pulling it apart and ordering parts. The shop wants me to endorse the check over to them to pay for the parts. $2300 in parts $4500 check from insurance company (which I and the body shop need to endorse to cash).

The work has barely been started and I can imagine MANY, MANY things that can go wrong with this scenario. Such as them taking 6 months to do the work. The shop going out of business. Not fixing the car to my satisfaction. The shop claims they'll just use the $2300 needed for parts and reimburse me the other $2200. I can see that check bouncing and i'll be out $4400, from my pocket.

The adjuster wasn't too helpful. He told me, 'you could do that, but I wouldn't.'

Is this something that comes up? I shouldn't give them anything at this point, should I?

In Car Insurance > Insurance Claims
8 answers - 618 days ago

Answer this Question

Watch this Question | Email to a Friend

Note: Per our Visitor Agreement, Edmunds.com does not guarantee the accuracy of any answers. We recommend that you use common sense when following any advice found here.

Voted Best Answer

avatar

mr_shiftright

Date: Feb 07, 2008
Time: 11:15 PM

Get it out of there.

Answers

avatar

mr_shiftright

Date: Feb 07, 2008
Time: 11:15 PM

Get it out of there.

avatar

noname8

Date: Feb 07, 2008
Time: 11:20 PM

I'd love to at this point. But how? I'm prety sure the insuance company won't go for that and neither will the shop. somebody's gonna want more money! What a PITA.
Thanks tho

avatar

0patience

Date: Feb 07, 2008
Time: 11:37 PM

Talk to your insurance agent and tell them that you decided to go to another shop and that you want the check made out to you, so you can make a decision on who to take it to.

I've never had them make it out to a shop.

avatar

simpilot1

Date: Feb 08, 2008
Time: 06:55 AM

Absolutely not. They have your car as collateral for the repair. There is no valid reason for them to require payment in advance.

avatar

madmanmoo

Date: Feb 08, 2008
Time: 03:03 PM

Shifty got it right. Yoink that vehicle.

Find someone else to do the work.

avatar

noname8

Date: Feb 08, 2008
Time: 09:16 PM

Yep. pretty much just considering pulling the vehicle at this point. I'll talk to the adjuster regarding that.

Unfortunaltey I picked this shop based on a buddys recomendation. Talked to the guy on the phone and now I regret that.

The shop owner is pretty P.O.'d since I brought the adjuster into it. But if he's a legit guy, you would think he would get WHY I don't want to hand over my collateral. I give him the check, he has my car, and payment. I'm not trying to be the world's worst customer, but I gotta look out for my best interest.

Everybody I talked to, agents, other shops, friends in the auto business, friends in general said it's a bad idea to give him anything. 99% said to yank the car.

avatar

arcardinal1

Date: Mar 17, 2008
Time: 06:57 PM

The whole idea behind both you and the body shop being on the check is to pay for the cost of repair. Endorsing the check over before the work is done should come with instructions on how to wave bye-bye.

Confirm with the shop that your signature will go on the check at the time the repairs are complete and to your satisfaction. The body shop had a mechanic's lien on the car the second the first bolt was loosened. If the shop doesn't have the money to buy the parts, they may not have the money to pay the help, either. Worst case scenario is the shop permanently closes its doors with your car inside.

My suggestion is to get the car to a shop you trust; contact the insurance carrier; and get the check reissued to you and the new shop. The new shop will payoff the current shop's time and add it to your bill.

avatar

bandit10

Date: Mar 18, 2008
Time: 02:49 AM

I had that situation with the Hartford Insurance company. But over the phone they told me if I took the car to one of their reccomened repair shops, that they would deal directly with the body shop and diburse monies as needed for repair to the shop. I did take to one of their shops, and as it turned out the original estamate was for $2,800 during the course of tering down the front end other areas needed replacement that could not be seen at the time because visabilty is minamal just looking before repairs are done. The damage turned out to $3,590. I never saw a check and all was handled by the Hartfort and the body shop. Call your insurance company and see if they have a prefered list of shops. If so you get the job done right, and no aggrevation on your part.

Source: 1998 Toyota 4Runner SR5

Answer this Question

View More

Top Insurance Claims Experts

Rank Leader Points
1. mr_shiftright 275
2. simpilot1 85
3. karjunkie 50
4. tony78 35
5. Wwillt 35
6. canddmeyer 30
7. la4mead 30

Edmunds Newsletter

  • Subscribe to the Edmunds Automotive Network Newsletter and enter the $500 Gas Card Sweepstakes. Sign up now and enter for your chance to win a $500 Gas Card! Official Rules