Edmunds Answers



  • knowledgepower 04/10/10 12:03 am PST

    Don't go by name only even though they own several auctions and is a well run organization. Just because the name is Manheim dealers still take their unwanted vehicles there to be sold. Remember this regardless of what you're told, dealers send ALL their unwanted vehicles there and to any auction. They are mixed in with some great deals but which one do I pick when there is little or no time to look them over. At least with a private seller you could drive the vehicle and do a Carfax vehicle report. I just happened to have seen it from the dealer side and there were a few good ones that got away. It's a coin flip when you go, take a good mechanic and even they can't indentify every problem. Keep in mind this is not a store to pick out what you want and leave, you bid against other people for the better vehicles so the couple thousand saved can evaporate with a biddding war on a good car. Make your decision and good luck to you.

  • zaken1 04/10/10 12:31 am PST

    There are many, many wholesale auto auctions across the country. The quality of the vehicles sold at the different auctions probably is pretty similar. It is not so much that one brand of auction is better or worse than any other. Instead; the problem with auction vehicles is that it is not possible to thoroughly evaluate a car's condition without test driving and inspecting it mechanically. The cars that end up being sold at auctions get there for a variety of reasons; but it is usually because they have been repossessed, recovered after being stolen, unloaded by insurance companies; or dumped there by dealers who couldn't sell the car. In other words; auction vehicles are MUCH more likely to have been abused, neglected, or to have undisclosed mechanical problems than the cars you encounter anywhere else. And many of these problams will not be visible; especially to an untrained person. If you find a nice looking, late model Mercedes there, for example; it may be tempting to put in a high bid and buy it on the spot. But what will you do if it turns out that the automatic transmission is shot; because some jerk ran it without any fluid in it? Do you have any idea how much it costs to replace the automatic transmission in a high end Mercedes??? It would easily cost far more than the few thousand dollars you would save on the initial purchase cost.

    This is why an untrained person should NEVER buy a car from an auction without fulfilling at least two basic prerequisites: One is being totally willing to accept the possibility that the purchase money you spend might end up being just the tip of a massive iceberg of necessary repair costs. If you need the overall cost of an auction car to not exceed a strict budget; you have no business buying a car there. This is a place for speculators who can afford to take risks; not for people who are already living beyond their means, and who are dreaming of saving a few bucks.

    The second absolute requirement (in my book) for buying a car at an auction is to bring a fully QUALIFIED, EXPERIENCED MECHANIC with you; who preferably has successfully evaluated cars at auctions before. Since some things cannot be tested; the mechanic must know what the risks are on a given vehicle, and be willing to rule out those cars which are potential bad deals because of the reputation of that brand; or the likely kind of abuse a car has suffered. And the money it will cost you to contract with such a mechanic will be ultimately worth far more than the amount you pay them. Here again; if you are unhappy with having to pay a mechanic to save you from a potential disaster; you don't belong at an auction.

  • isellhondas 04/11/10 3:33 pm PST

    We buy cars at the auction all of the time and we never drive them.

    Rarely do we have a problem but our buyers are very experienced and they know what they are doing.

    Unless you have the skills they have, I wouldn't do it.

  • racer543 01/23/15 11:52 am PST

    Dude, my experience with them is that they are extremely shady. Think about it: You're buying cars that have been repoed meaning that people could not afford them -- or to maintain them. You're taking a huge risk buying from them especially since they won't stand behind the vehicle.

    If you do have a problem or when you ask questions, everybody claims to not know anything and then blows you off to another person who says the same thing. I would stay away.


Top Car Buying Experts View More

Rank Leader Points
1. Stever@Edmunds 11010
2. MrShift@Edmunds 7065
3. morin2 5555
4. karjunkie 4145
5. texases 3920
6. knowledgepower 3590
7. zaken1 2235