Edmunds Answers



  • knowledgepower 07/17/12 7:05 pm PST

    It's all about dollars and sense, you seem to have the dollars to buy the vehicle and the sense to compare 2012 to 2013. If you buy the 2012 Subaru at a .9% interest rate it is outstanding because it's almost like borrowing money with no rate at all. Don't listen to the haters who would say you're buying a year old car. Let's be real, you will save on insurance because it's a year earlier and it's the same car one year to another. The purchase price of the vehicles are close but of course the 2012 will be cheaper. You win both ways in interest rate,a little cheaper insurance and you're financing less money for nothing.


  • morin2 07/17/12 10:13 pm PST

    Like so many things "It Depends". If you intend to keep the car for a long time, say 10 years, then it won't matter much which year you buy for depreciation. However, you have to do the math with the interest rates. If you have excellent credit, you'll get pretty low rates anyway - under 4%. Factor in any incentives on the leftover too, and how much you will be financing. If the purchase price is similar for both years, I'd be inclined to buy the 2013 and make a large down payment, minimizing the amount financed, and the total amount of interest paid. Check with your bank or credit union first to see what they'll offer you for rates and then let the dealer try to beat it (often, they can). I agree with the 36 month term.

    One reason to go with the newer car if prices are similar and there are no real changes and you intend to keep for a long time is the potential for insurance payment in the event of a totalled wreck. If someone smashes your 2012, it will be valued by the insurance company as a 1 year old car, while the 2013 will be valued as new and you would get a bigger settlement check. Let's hope it doesn't happen to you, but it did happen to my new subaru and I was happy that I hadn't chosen a brand with high depreciation or a leftover. I'd still consider a leftover - but it would have to be deeply discounted.

    Good luck!


Top Car Buying Incentives / Rebates Experts View More

Rank Leader Points
1. Stever@Edmunds 1090
2. MrShift@Edmunds 455
3. knowledgepower 315
4. morin2 175
5. boomchek 150
6. karjunkie 120
7. sylvia 120