Answers

Ask Questions Answer Questions Browse Questions

Search for questions:

My Answers Profile

Question

Question Details

Asked: Jan 04, 2008 - 08:04 AM

Status: Closed

What do people mean when they say "quality" while referring to a car?

I am an owner of a Honda cCivic and in the proocess of buying a new car. I wanted to know what people mean when they say "quality" car. Which make has the best quality?

In Buying & Selling > Car Comparisons
6 answers - 402 days ago

Answer this Question

Watch this Question | Email to a Friend

Note: Per our Visitor Agreement, Edmunds.com does not guarantee the accuracy of any answers. We recommend that you use common sense when following any advice found here.

Edmunds.com Staff Answers

avatar

researchqueen

Date: Jul 24, 2008
Time: 18:00

I have your perfect answer: the Edmunds article, What Do You Mean By Vehicle Quality?

Voted Best Answer

avatar

autoboy16

Date: Jan 08, 2008
Time: 06:27 PM

When I think quality, I think of materials used. For Example:Test drive a Pontiac Grand Prix. From the start, you'll notice the VAST amounts of plastic and rubber. The grand prix has its igniton in the dash. If you have a lot of keys, all you hear is metal banging plastic! Then the Engine has a tinny electronic sound and the seats aren't very comfortable. While you're seated, you arm rests on hard unpadded plastic and you have to touch the cheap and flimsy feeling controls to get the whole experience. That is not qualiy!


Sure its cheaper than say a VW passat but you get what you pay for! In a Passat, the leatherette is firm but its comfortable! The engine sounds growlie and great(even the turbo!)! Sure VW uses plastic, but nowhere near the same extent of the Grand Prix! There is comfortable leatherette/vinyl or leather pads where your arms would rest and all the controls feel solid and well put togather! Even the doors close with a solid "thunk!".

On top of that, VW gives you many more features and better quality for a few thousand more. Remember the old saying, "You get what you pay for!"

Quality is subjunctive and I would gladly pay the extra $$$ for a Passat before I would the Grand Prix. Even the old generation Passat is a solid choice against the current Grand Prix.

-Cj

Source: Personal Experience

Answers

avatar

mr_shiftright

Date: Jan 07, 2008
Time: 05:54 PM

Well you'll get some interesting answers, so I'll kick in my two cents.

I think most people mean one of two things when they say "quality":

one would be "reliability", like say a Toyota Corolla represents "Toyota Quality"

A second interpretation would be what we call "fit and finish"--that is, the car is put together with quality materials, paint and assembly--so the car "looks like" a quality item, regardless if it's not the most reliable car on the road statistically.

avatar

jipster

Date: Jan 07, 2008
Time: 06:16 PM

When someone says they want a "quality" car, they are referring to Japanese made.

avatar

madmanmoo

Date: Jan 08, 2008
Time: 04:01 PM

Quality would be a vehicle that is reliable and looks good. Fit and finish is solid. That's how I describe 'quality'.

It's definitely from whoever's mouth it's coming though.

avatar

autoboy16

Date: Jan 08, 2008
Time: 06:27 PM

When I think quality, I think of materials used. For Example:Test drive a Pontiac Grand Prix. From the start, you'll notice the VAST amounts of plastic and rubber. The grand prix has its igniton in the dash. If you have a lot of keys, all you hear is metal banging plastic! Then the Engine has a tinny electronic sound and the seats aren't very comfortable. While you're seated, you arm rests on hard unpadded plastic and you have to touch the cheap and flimsy feeling controls to get the whole experience. That is not qualiy!


Sure its cheaper than say a VW passat but you get what you pay for! In a Passat, the leatherette is firm but its comfortable! The engine sounds growlie and great(even the turbo!)! Sure VW uses plastic, but nowhere near the same extent of the Grand Prix! There is comfortable leatherette/vinyl or leather pads where your arms would rest and all the controls feel solid and well put togather! Even the doors close with a solid "thunk!".

On top of that, VW gives you many more features and better quality for a few thousand more. Remember the old saying, "You get what you pay for!"

Quality is subjunctive and I would gladly pay the extra $$$ for a Passat before I would the Grand Prix. Even the old generation Passat is a solid choice against the current Grand Prix.

-Cj

Source: Personal Experience

avatar

researchqueen

Date: Jul 24, 2008
Time: 06:00 PM

I have your perfect answer: the Edmunds article, What Do You Mean By Vehicle Quality?

avatar

nrms3

Date: Oct 19, 2008
Time: 07:44 PM

Quality, in vehicular terms, is actually more subjective than you may think. Of course, the factors themselves are mostly objective, however when one hops into a car, they judge often by the impression they get from the car's "feel."

For me, what gives me a good quality "feel" is:

1. Material
2. Stability
3. Reliability
4. Comfort
5. Design

Japanese and German brands usually, but not always have good quality. Some say domestic brands have improving quality, but this is only parially true. More than being foreign or domestic, however, is the brand itself, or even vehicle. For example, a Honda has much better build quality than a Mitsubishi, but they both are from Japan. A Malibu is so much more refined than an Aveo, you'd think they were by entirely different companies (oh, that's right... the Aveo is a Korean Daewoo...).

Currently, as for a "mainstream" automaker, the answer to the best quality would probably be Honda. Volkswagens aren't quite as "mainstream," but they do have great refinement. However, Volkswagens have awful reliability, and to buy one would be... well... "suicidal" in car terms.

Answer this Question

OTHER QUESTIONS NEEDING ANSWERS

is VW cabrio a good car?
View More

Top Car Comparisons Experts

Rank Leader Points
1. karjunkie 1405
2. mr_shiftright 1040
3. steve_ 915
4. texases 565
5. zaken1 545
6. tony78 520
7. canddmeyer 365

Edmunds Newsletter

  • Subscribe to the Edmunds Automotive Network Newsletter and enter the $500 Gas Card Sweepstakes. Sign up now and enter for your chance to win a $500 Gas Card! Official Rules