Answers

Ask Questions Answer Questions Browse Questions

Search for questions:

My Answers Profile

Question

Question Details

Asked: Jan 08, 2009 - 10:25 AM

Status: Closed

Can the battery be the cause for a car stall? Hyundai Elantra.

A couple days ago, my dad had to replace the battery and the cable in his car because it stalled on him on a freeway. But the car stalled again the night of the repair. He believes that he had been scammed.

I'm not sure if I should be posting up questions as such on this site, but since I have no knowledge regarding automotive vehicles to decide whether a scam has been taken place or not, I decided to post up a question on this site to get some answers if possible.

His car is about 10 years old I believe. It has given him much trouble and repairing the past few years, but he needs it for just one more year to save up money for a new car, if it still does have some 'juice' left in it. He was driving at about 60 mph when the car stalled on him. The battery is about 4 years old. The mechanic at 'pep boys' said that the battery had died on him and that would fix the car. So the mechanic changed the battery and the cable.
Is it possible that the battery could have been the cause for the car stalling? If it is.. why would it have stalled again? If not what other problems could have caused the old car to stall? or are there too many options to just speculate?

please give me some answers. and thank you for your time.

In Makes & Models > Hyundai > Elantra
In Maintenance & Repair > Engine > Stalling
In Maintenance & Repair > Electrical > Battery
3 answers - 322 days ago

Answer this Question

Watch this Question | Email to a Friend

Note: Per our Visitor Agreement, Edmunds.com does not guarantee the accuracy of any answers. We recommend that you use common sense when following any advice found here.

Voted Best Answer

avatar

texases

Date: Jan 08, 2009
Time: 02:18 PM

What might have happened here is that the alternator, which charges the battery, is bad. Once the old battery went dead, the car stalled. The new battery was charged to begin with, so it worked for a while, but without the alternator charging it, it also died, and the car stalled. Your dad needs to have the battery charged and the alternator tested. If the alternator is ok, then it's something else. Good luck!

Answers

avatar

tony78

Date: Jan 08, 2009
Time: 01:58 PM

i will try and answer your question in the order that you presented it.

1. This site is for anyone to ask about anything that is automotive related and i sometimes think that a site such as this can be used for anything related to anything,,now that last part may sound a little foolish,but i think that many people,,when making a decision,,need someone,,anyone to present the idea to,,to get some feedback from,,people feel more comfortable with this,,it helps them " put things into perspective ".

2. At around 10 yrs or so,,the vast majority of cars,,regardless of the make or model ( as some salesmen / women would like you to believe ) start to " wear out ". The first 5 years you made payments. The second 5 years are the honeymoon. After that it's all down hill baby !

3.As for the battery and the battery being defective,,the simple answer is yes,,a defective battery can make an engine stall,,you see,,the cars ignition system,,thats the part that makes the spark plugs " fire ",,is directly tied to the battery,,,The cars alternator supplies electricity to the battery,and the battery supplies electricity to the spark plugs,,,remove the battery,,there is no electricity to the spark plugs,,and voila ! the car stalls.

You chose the correct word when you said " options ",,yes there are several other areas that may have a potential problem that can cause a car to stall. And within those areas,,there are individual components that can contribute to the " stall ".

avatar

texases

Date: Jan 08, 2009
Time: 02:18 PM

What might have happened here is that the alternator, which charges the battery, is bad. Once the old battery went dead, the car stalled. The new battery was charged to begin with, so it worked for a while, but without the alternator charging it, it also died, and the car stalled. Your dad needs to have the battery charged and the alternator tested. If the alternator is ok, then it's something else. Good luck!

avatar

daisybuttons

Date: Jan 09, 2009
Time: 03:19 AM

You say that this old car has been worked on-what else has been fixied on it? This may hold a key as to why the battery doesn't hold a charge or may be going dead-and by the battery being as old as it is may be the problem also-but elaborate on what else has been done to the car. And Have you researched this car to see if there have been any problems with other cars like his that may have something that required a recall of this vehicle? or at least something that may have been an issue of bringing it back in for repairs of some kind! I'm not a mechanic-and not a master of this domain-but I've had trouble with my car-and found out that it did have a defect that required that I bring it back to the dealership to have something done to it in order for me to quit having battery problems-so I just wanted you to know that you need to check this out! These good PPL in this website have helped me very much! My dealership didn't want to listen to me the first time I took my car back-but the second time-it was just as these ppl told me-what was wrong with my car-and the dealership fixed it-without another word said!

Answer this Question

View More

Top Hyundai Elantra Experts

Rank Leader Points
1. karjunkie 110
2. mr_shiftright 80
3. docj 55
4. patrick88 45
5. 0patience 35
6. kiawah 30
7. subearu 30

Edmunds Newsletter

  • Subscribe to the Edmunds Automotive Network Newsletter and enter the $500 Gas Card Sweepstakes. Sign up now and enter for your chance to win a $500 Gas Card! Official Rules